Sunday, November 16, 2014

To Test or Not to Test?


The New York Times recently reported that parents in Royal Palm Beach, Florida rallied to voice their frustrations with the number of standardized tests that have come pouring in from district, state, and federal levels. Some are concerned that their teenagers have to take anxiety pills to cope with stress; others mentioned the fact that some teachers would rather retire than "promote a culture that seems to value testing over learning." The influx of tests are due to the state trying to fulfill federal grant obligations on teacher evaluations, and also due to the district trying to keep up with the new Common Core standards, which are making standards harder and standardized tests much more difficult. All of these tests, in addition to SATs, ACTs, and AP tests, are weighing down heavily on the students, and on the teachers who instruct them. Many schools in Florida this year will dedicate 60-80 out of 180 school days for standardized testing. Now, the question is this - Is this what we call "quality education"?

In my opinion, standardized testing is not an accurate assessment on a student's academic ability. I also believe that implementing an increased number of standardized tests creates a learning environment in which the teachers are forced to "teach to a test". Arne Duncan said that the teachers have not had enough time to adapt to these new standards and tests. When the teachers have to adapt and change their way of teaching to meet new, harder standards, the students suffer from bad test scores. When students get bad test scores, it reflects poorly on them, on the teachers, and on the schools. Because the students get bad test scores on the tests that the government uses as evaluators, schools and teachers get less money to function, and this limits the resources that the students are able to receive to get a quality education. Then the cycle repeats.

America's education system is flawed, and needs drastic changes. Students nowadays are just taking in information that they need to get good grades on tests, instead of actually learning and retaining the material that they need to succeed in the real world. I've seen first-hand that students in 12th grade just work to get the "A", so that they can satisfy parents, colleges, etc. What I think that the government should do is stop making formulas and standards that "equally evaluate" students. The government needs to stop creating a system of education that conforms students to what they believe are apt standards. If we keep going down this road, free-thinking and actual learning will be a thing of the past.

2 comments:

  1. I agree with the fact that the government shouldn't force schools to teach an entirely new system of education to teachers and students, so that they may perform well on standardized tests. As much as many of us don't want to think about it, these tests can end up affecting our future and the paths we take, causing some individuals to feel the tremendous amount of anxiety that you mentioned. It's also unfair because some people do not test as well as others, and this could lead to some people feeling inferior or superior compared to the people around them. I believe that our education system needs to be fixed and that instead of focusing on just the grades and numbers students receive, school should focus on making sure that students become more knowledgeable.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The tests don't assess learning nearly as much as economic level, so poor schools are easily branded as "failing" and their teachers labelled "ineffective." This pseudoscience is destroying public schools and teachers careers on top of wasting kids educational time. Check out Mr. Bezanis's post on the time spent at Central: http://phillyteachersdesk.blogspot.com/2014/12/180-days-of-instruction-are-you-sure.html

    ReplyDelete